Die By The Blade: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: College Football Rankings - BlogPoll Top 25

Trade Deadline Reporting 2010: Rumors, Insiders and Pretenders

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

It’s almost March 3rd, and a perfect storm could be brewing.  An inundation of data in a high tech world may force Internet Armageddon upon us.  If the brainiacs who helped us avoid the Y2K disaster a decade ago can be found, then someone might want to try and round them up. 

The dizziness that we NHL diehards experience in the coming days won’t be the result of an unusually high number of hockey transactions, but from the methods that updates will be produced and consumed.  It’s going to be a wild ride on the information overload speed train for three main reasons:

- It’ll be trade deadline week, and hockey fans just love their trade rumors;

- Many credible and trusted hockey media insiders are now using Twitter;

- Many phony rumor spreading reporter wannabees are now using Twitter.

Welcome to hockey journalism in the post-web 2.0 world, where any half-literate dreamer, armed with only a keyboard and a seventh grade knowledge of spelling and sentence structure, can piggyback public updates from Bob McKenzie and Darren Dreger and broadcast them as scoops from "inside sources" to thousands of information-starved hockey fans.

Star-divide

 

One can only imagine what rumor reporting will be like leading up to the first NHL trade deadline of the Twitter Age after all of the unprofessional, uncorroborated, and even comedic material that we’ve witnessed these past few years throughout much of the blogosphere.

Some rumor bloggers have their own odd habits and tendencies.  One site well known for false rumors has developed an odd propensity for linking the Buffalo Sabres to guys that previously played there.  In the past two years, the site in question has had Daniel Briere, Michael Peca, Jay McKee, Martin Biron, Miroslav Satan and Rhett Warrener all returning to Buffalo. 

No mention of Mike Grier though…

A select few of these rumor bloggers and tweeters have actually established quite a following.  On the surface, the success of some of them seems so mystifying.  Why would anyone want to look for rumors and inside information from non-reporters who have done nothing but shot blanks time and time again?

Their popularity has spawned into a professional wrestling mentality.  You know that the source of what you’re watching is phony and idiotic but you can’t help but look at it.  In some cases you have to see what levity these jokers can come up with next because you’re curious as to what levels they can embarrass themselves.

The fine quality work of guys named Kukla, Mirtle, Richardson, and Wyshynski has been the inspiration for many dreamers to launch websites and twitter accounts, and to instantly refer to themselves as insiders, despite having as many connections as the guy in the top row of the nosebleed seats. 

While there are certainly some good rumor bloggers out there who write well and always cite reliable sources, there are others who just make you roll your eyes.  With some simple acid tests it’s easy to tell who the phonies are:

The Vanity Test: If they get offended by being referred to as a blogger rather than a columnist then you may have a live one.  This despite the fact that reading some of their articles reminds you of when your 12-year-old son comes home and asks you to review his English homework.  Well, at least your kid is diligent enough to find a proofreader.

The Pseudo-Insider Test: If they claim to know someone - a front office employee, a guy who dated the GM’s daughter, or the second cousin of an agent - then that should tell you something.  Hockey rumor blogging has become the only hobby where having an imaginary friend makes you intriguing instead of weird.

The Rationalization Test: If they face ridicule after a player goes to a team that wasn’t on their list of 17 possible destinations, and their defense is that they’re simply reporting chatter based on what their "sources" are telling them, then it’s conceivable that you could find a dartboard with 30 NHL team logos on it in their basement.

During Ilya Kovalchuk sweeps week, respected hockey writer Pierre LeBrun said that an NHL executive told him he wouldn’t be surprised if the Blackhawks went after the star forward.  The vultures got their claws on this one in no time.  It went viral and was twisted into a fallacy that Kovalchuk was Chicago bound and Cam Barker was headed to Atlanta.  What LeBrun reported was certainly credible; what the rumormongers made out of it was totally fabricated.

And now, with the implementation of Twitter by insiders and pretenders alike, we’ll be seeing a whole lot more of "My sources are telling me…" in the next few days.

Enjoy the upcoming circus known as the trade deadline, hockey fans.  To the credible writers that keep us informed, keep up the good work.  And to all of you fake rumor blogging and tweeting non-reporters out there – thanks in advance for the laughs!

Follow me on Twitter: @DaveDavisHockey

1 recs  |  Comment 4 comments |

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

I love the irony at the end – Follow me on Twitter!

"Grind now, shine later." - Wesley Johnson

by Afino on Feb 27, 2010 2:04 PM EST reply actions  

Yup.......Exhibit A

The Buffalo Bills SB site had literally hundreds of threads for weeks and all with unfounded rumors, gossips, supposed “Inside information,” tweets, etc. on who was going to be the GM and then who was going to be head coach. All of those “insights” turned out to be B.S., Most of the time, these type of threads are all over SB nation have one-tenth the credibility you see in your average supermarket tabloid. It’s okay – it’s fun to guess (imagine the rumors here when Ruff retires or is fired) – but a lot of these bloggers actually take themselves seriously, even though none of them make a living writing sports.

by ccthemovieman on Feb 27, 2010 2:23 PM EST reply actions  

So what are some recommendations for some good hockey rumor sites or people to follow on twitter?

I love MLBtraderumors.com for baseball, but haven’t found anything close for hockey.

by Monotonousblob on Feb 27, 2010 5:09 PM EST reply actions  

Exhibit B

Read this minutes ago from a prominent hockey rumor site:

*Talked to one player who talked to a teammate who was told he was traded in the last few minutes but may not be announced until morning…

A friend of a friend told you? And no names mentioned at all? It must be true.

by Andy Boron on Mar 1, 2010 12:21 AM EST reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation blog about Buffalo Sabres. It is the most interactive Sabres site on the web.

Community Guidelines
Start posting about the Sabres »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

Connect_with_facebook

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Small
Remaining UFAs
Headshot_small
New SB Nation Feature - Fan Confidence Poll
Small
Sabres sign LW Stuart
Small
Bring Back Jay McKee
Iron_maiden_eddie_trooper_small
It's not who they brought in...it's who they haven't shipped out
Forest_small
How sabres measure up, over the last 20 years
Small
Kovy's contract rejected
Small
Good Article by Ek
Usc_gamecocks_small
New Sabres Uniforms?
100_3785_small
NHL.com 30-in-30 Article

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

Twitter Box

SBNation.com Recent Stories

Photo link

Dan Ellis Leaves Twitter; Can Athletes Have Truly Honest Public Opinions?

Photo +5 updates

SB Nation's Mock NHL Expansion Draft: Winnipeg And Quebec Select Their Teams

Vancouver Canucks' Willie Mitchell, centre, reacts as Calgary Flames' Michael Cammalleri, left to right, Jarome Iginla and Olli Jokinen, of Finland, celebrate Iginla's goal during second period NHL hockey action at GM Place in Vancouver, Tuesday, April 7, 2009.  (AP Photo/The Canadian Press, Jonathan Hayward) link

Is Willie Mitchell A Socialist?

More from SBNation.com >


Editor-in-Chief

Headshot_small Zachary Zielonka

Writers

Dopic_small David Oleksy

211_talking_proud_1_small krytime

Small Bakes

Hamstergolfhd4_small Andy Boron

Kovy_small Rafal Ladysz

Hansons25c_small Dave Davis

Stroud_pre2_small BBFan4Ever