How The Sabres Can Improve at Trade Deadline
I have been a believer in this Buffalo Sabres team for the last three years and I still believe they have most of the pieces of a Stanley Cup contender. With their play in recent weeks it has become obvious that the key parts are in place but they need some complimentary players to improve the team at the deadline.
If we want to figure out what players they should target at the trade deadline we need to decide the biggest weaknesses on the team. There is no real consensus among Sabres fans as to what the biggest need on the team really is.
Some of you have targeted a quarterback for the power play and others don't think Henrik Tallinder and Tyler Myers can be a shutdown defensive pair in the playoffs. Still others feel the offense is the problem and the top six forwards aren't good enough to score big goals. There are many opinions on the Sabres needs and that talk has increased with the recent five game winless streak.
This team does not need a major shakeup. They have a few missing pieces that could be used to compliment the talent that is already in the room. I see the biggest need on the third line. A couple of pieces to compliment the hard work and toughness of Mike Grier.
Tim Kennedy was fine in the beginning of the season, and he will be in the future, but it's easy to see his struggles as the race to playoffs has begun. Paul Gaustad is a valuable part of the team but he is nothing more than an overpriced fourth liner, his deficiencies are apparent when he is forced onto the third line. Don't get me started on Clarke MacArthur. I defended him against all the naysayers and he has been a liability to this team over the last couple of months. There is not a defensive bone in his body and his offense leaves a little to be desired.
The biggest need for the team is a third line left winger and a third line center. I'm not opposed to improving the defense but I think the players on the roster can do the job with Ryan Miller playing behind them. Miller has struggled some in recent weeks but when he finds his game the defensive worries will be put to rest.
Keep in mind the first trade deadline is Friday at 3 p.m. when there is a trade freeze for the Olympics and the real trade deadline on March 3.
Follow the jump for a look at players the Sabres might target.
Making trades this season might be difficult because there will probably be more buyers than sellers. There is an abundance of teams that are still in the playoff hunt and may not want to dump there assets. I have compiled a list of players that might be available for the Sabres to acquire.
Minnesota Wild - C-Eric Belanger, D-Marek Zidlicky, RW-Owen Nolan
NY Islanders - C-Doug Weight, D-Andy Sutton
Columbus Blue Jackets - LW RJ Umberger, LW- Raffi Torres, LW-Fredrick Modin
Edmonton Oilers - RW-Fernando Pisani, C-Mike Comrie, C-Andrew Cogliano, C-Gilbert Brule, D-Denis Grebeshkov
Florida Panthers - LW-Cory Stillman, C-Gregory Campbell, D-Dennis Seidenberg, D-Jordan Leopold
Carolina Hurricanes - LW-Ray Whitney, C-Matt Cullen, D-Joe Corvo, D-Aaron Ward
Toronto Maple Leafs - LW-Alexei Ponikarovsky, RW-Lee Stempniak
Phoenix Coyotes - C-Peter Mueller
Dallas Stars - LW-Steve Ott
Atlanta Thrashers - RW-Colby Armstrong
Players the Sabres Should Target
Ponikarovsky is a big guy that would fit perfectly with the Sabres. He could play on the third line but he could also step in as a top six forward is necessary. He is a left wing but has known to play on the rights side at times when necessary. His versatility would be welcome when injuries strike in the playoffs.
Ott would be the perfect fit on the Sabres third line. The Stars don't want to part with Ott but his salary demands have been too rich for the Stars and they might give in and move him for the right deal. Ott would bring the toughness that every Sabres fan has been clamoring for since time began. He can also contribute offensively which would help him fit in with Mike Grier on the third line.
If the Sabres can't acquire Ott than Torres would be another fine addition to the Sabres third line. Torres is a hard nosed player that will battle in the corners and can contribute offensively. Sabres fans seen first hand the type of player he is when the Sabres were shutout in Columbus last week.
Honorable Mention Left Wingers: RJ Umberger (Columbus Blue Jackets), Ray Whitney (Carolina Hurricanes)
Belanger doesn't have the size that Sabres fans would like to see but he has offensive upside and his faceoff ability would be incredibly useful for the Sabres. Belanger is another player that contributes offensively but he is also responsible in his own zone and could compliment Grier on the third line.
Cullen is more the type of player that Sabres fans would like to see in a Sabres uniform. He has the size to be a power forward and he can contribute in both the offensive and defensive zone. Although Cullen could be a perfect fit as a third line center he will not improve the Sabres faceoff abilities. He is under 50% on the season which would rank him along with the Sabres current players.
Honorable Mention Centers: Gilbert Brule (Edmonton Oilers), Peter Mueller (Phoenix Coyotes), Doug Weight (NY Islanders)
0 recs |
23 comments
|
Comments
I listed him in the honorable mention for wingers. I like the size of the other wingers more than I like Whitney. Whitney will obviously help offensively but he is a one dimensional player in my opinion.
D.O.
www.diebytheblade.com - An SB nation destination for Sabres fans everywhere
by David Oleksy on Feb 11, 2010 1:06 PM EST up reply actions
I should add
I like Whitney as a player and I think he could help this team. I think the risk out weighs the reward with Whitney. You would have to give up too much to get him. There has been talk that he would like an extension wherever he goes and that would help the cause. If the Sabres were to add Whitney there would have to be some subtractions as well. I’m not sure they want to make wholesale changes coming down the stretch, they just need a couple of players to plug into the holes.
D.O.
www.diebytheblade.com - An SB nation destination for Sabres fans everywhere
by David Oleksy on Feb 11, 2010 1:18 PM EST up reply actions
I am not a fan of Pitkanen
I would take Joe Corvo before I would take Pitkanen. He is an expensive player that is more offensive than defensive. If they are going to pay Pitkanen $4 million they should have just signed Spacek in the summer.
D.O.
www.diebytheblade.com - An SB nation destination for Sabres fans everywhere
by David Oleksy on Feb 11, 2010 1:08 PM EST up reply actions
I would also take two or three other defensemen before Pitkanen. Jordan Leopold would be at the top of my list but I would rather have Grebeshkov or Seidenburg as well. I have never been a fan of Pitkanen. There is a reason he was run out of every town he has been in and many Canes fans would like him gone as well.
D.O.
www.diebytheblade.com - An SB nation destination for Sabres fans everywhere
by David Oleksy on Feb 11, 2010 1:15 PM EST up reply actions
i gotta strongly disagree dave
pitkanen is averaging about a point per game over the last 15 games or so and if there’s any reason he’s disliked it’s because of his injury history. grebeshkov is a player similar to pitkanen but less talented and leopold and seidenberg won’t do much good, it’s offense we need. finally, corvo just got back from a long lay-off and he’s not only less than 100 per cent, but he mentioned that he doesn’t believe he will be fully fit until next year. Grabbing him in this kind of condition would just be idiotic.
by Rafal Ladysz on Feb 11, 2010 2:33 PM EST up reply actions
All the players listed have positives and negatives
Why would we want a one dimensional defenseman to be the highest paid blueliner on the team? Pitkanen will bring offense but he is a liability in his own end. He has been a minus player in three of his last four seasons.
Jordan Leopold will not only bring just as much offense as Pitkanen but he’ll do it at a much cheaper cap price. He will also be a free agent so he will be nothing more than rental. Pitkanen is still signed. As for the other players I just like the cheaper price as opposed to an overpaid defenseman.
D.O.
www.diebytheblade.com - An SB nation destination for Sabres fans everywhere
by David Oleksy on Feb 11, 2010 3:18 PM EST up reply actions
The way I see it
I haven’t watched Pikanen a whole lot but I feel you’re undervaluing him defensively. He’s definitely not a shut-down guy or a flashy D-man who throws huge hits or anything but at the very least he is a solid contain defensman. Besides Myers we don’t really have anyone on D that you can call a real offensive asset (you could argue for Sekera, but he doesn’t play nearly often enough). Plus, Pitkanen and his 15 pp assists would automatically be slide into the QB role on a pp which has been ineffective for long stretches this year.
It terms of what it would take to get him, my thinking is probably something like a roster player, a mid-level prospect, and a 2nd round pick. That might translate to MacArthur or Sekera packaged with either 1 or 2 of Legace, Schiestel, or Brennan. If that isn’t enough I wouldn’t lose any sleep shipping Bulter to Carolina for him along with one of the prospects mentioned above and a 3rd rounder. Bulter, while good early, hasn’t impressed me lately and likely will be passed on the depth charts by Mike Weber when he gets here anyway. If we can get Pitkanen with out loosing Butler (which, of course, would be preferred), it would probably leave Lydman as the odd man out. Unlikely to come back next season anyway, he could be used in a package to get Ott or traded to a team looking to add defensive depth (like Vancouver or San Jose) for a mid round pick.
That would leave our D-pairings like this:
Myers – Tallinder
Rivet – Pitkanen
Montador – Butler/Lydman
Press box – Sekera, Paetsch
The other guys you mentioned (Leopold, Grebeshkov, and Seidenburg) would add minimal value. Seidenberg, in my opinion, is not a better option than anyone already on the roster. Grebeskov is similar to Sekera, though not as prone to defensive gaffs but is also probably not as good a skater. Leopold is a decent player, but probably doesn’t slot above Bulter or Montador. Coincidentally, Leopold has been a minus player in 3 of his last 4 seasons (4 out of 5 if you include this one).
There is a reason he was run out of every town he has been in and many Canes fans would like him gone as well.
Not sure where you got this but I don’t know of any fans that wants Joni gone. He is well like in Carolina, but then again we like all our Finns.
Staal + Jussi = GOAL
see below
Obviously a misinformed statement by me. I should have looked for another source.
It still doen’t change my opinion on him coming to Buffalo. I say no thank you.
D.O.
www.diebytheblade.com - An SB nation destination for Sabres fans everywhere
by David Oleksy on Feb 11, 2010 3:20 PM EST up reply actions
If Joni got traded it would be a huge loss for the Canes. In my opinion most fans think Joni is a key part of the rebuid. Joni is a fan favorite behind Gleason on defense.
Staal + Jussi = GOAL
I am proven wrong about Canes fans
I was basing my statement on a Canes fan that replied to an earlier post on Pitkanen.
D.O.
www.diebytheblade.com - An SB nation destination for Sabres fans everywhere
by David Oleksy on Feb 11, 2010 3:19 PM EST up reply actions
I wouldnt mind adding Dougie Weight or Owen Nolan to play alongside of Grier.
As far as D. I feel like we’ll add someone, but I just dont know who.
"Hey ey ey ey"
I’m an Islanders fan who happens to live in Upstate New York (which means that I watch my fair share of Sabres games). While Doug Weight was bit by the injury bug earlier this season, I do believe that his leadership and playoff experience would be beneficial to any team that does acquire his services at the trade deadline. In terms of promoting team depth along with leadership and playoff experience, Doug Weight may be a good fit for the Sabres, but probably a better fit for the L.A. Kings. I also would say that if the Sabres do trade for Weight, that they shouldn’t give up anything greater than a conditional draft pick (around the 5th or 6th round).
I think Ott would be excellent addtion to the Sabres for all of the reasons you give above. As for Ponikarovsky, what inducement could the Sabres offer to Toronto cause them to give him up? Certainly not C-Mac and a couple of draft choices.
Poni is a free agent
the Leafs will be happy with a draft pick much like they did with Moore and Antropov last season.
D.O.
www.diebytheblade.com - An SB nation destination for Sabres fans everywhere
by David Oleksy on Feb 11, 2010 5:05 PM EST up reply actions
I grew up watching Owen Nolan play in San Jose. I loved how hard he played back then and I think he would pair up really well with Mike Grier. He would add a level of grit that this team lacks. I’d love to see him in a Sabre Uniform. I just wonder if he’s a little too old.
"The three important elements of hockey are: forecheck, backcheck and paycheck." - Gil Perreault
Deal with Toronto?
I was a huge fan of Owen Nolan years ago… but, unfortunately, his best days are behind him. Keeping in mind that they have 2 third round picks this year and possibly 2 fourth round picks (if Paille can put home 7 more goals before the end of the season), I’d personally like to see them make one of the two following moves:
Choice 1: Jochen Hecht and Clarke MacArthur along with Buffalo’s 1st round pick to Toronto in exchange for Tomas Kaberle and Lee Stempniak (or Ponikarovsky).
Explanation: The Sabres only have slightly over $1.1 million in cap space (according to HockeyBuzz.com), so they would need to shed some salary to take in a guy like Kaberle. The Leafs want a 1st round pick for him and Regier has shown he’s willing to do that for the right player (ex. deal for Zubrus) and Kaberle has another year on his contract at $4.25 million (slightly more than Rivet makes). I believe Burke would eat a salary like Hecht’s (or maybe even Rivet instead) so long as he gets that 1st round pick.
Choice 2: Clarke MacArthur and Craig Rivet to Colorado for John-Michael Liles and Marek Svatos. Liles is small for a defenseman and is overpaid ($4 million per year for next 3 years), but he is great on the power play and for transitioning plays out of his zone. Svatos once scored 32 goals in his second season, but he’s only getting 12-13 minutes now and has lost his will for the Avalanche (similar to what happened with Max the last 2 years here). The Leafs are actually interested in Svatos, so he could possibly be sent on to Toronto for Stempniak then.
Last tidbit, I’d love to see the return of Marty Biron, but understand it probably won’t happen. Ruff just simply doesn’t have any faith in Lalime and I can’t say that I blame him, but in Lalime’s defense he has to play more consistently. I would love to see Regier add Raffi Torres, it would remind me of the deal he made for Steve Heinze years ago. Torres has 17 goals on the year while only averaging 13 minutes of ice time per game. That’s awesome!
DC Chocolate City!
by djc1877 on Feb 11, 2010 10:14 PM EST reply actions 1 recs
If choice one has Rivet instead of Hecht I'm down
Is it just me or does Hecht always seem to come up with the puck when he goes to the boards? Now grant it he doesn’t do much with it after but thats why he’s on a line with Connolly. I think Hecht is having his best season so I would like to keep him for the playoffs.
Rookies are like teabags...you don't know what you're gonna get until you put them in hot water. -Harry Neale
Umberger could never EVER play for the Sabres...
Not after that hit that Campbell laid on him. I bet he still feels it… I bet they still feel it in China!
P

by 
























